If this was fwd’d to you, subscribe here.

😀 MOTW (Meme of the Week) 😀

Is this a pigeon meme: customer pointing at the delivery photo of the box on their porch, asking 'Is this… not delivered?'

☺️ Hey, Hey, Heyyy! ☺️

BFCM is about a month out, and every brand I talk to is planning how to get the order. Almost nobody is planning what happens after it.

Here’s what I keep coming back to: the first order is the easy part. Whether that customer ever orders again comes down to what happens in the next 30 days. 😬

That’s not acquiring customers. That’s renting them for one sale. So this week: how to use the first 30 days to change that.

Why the first 30 days decide it 🗓️

The first month is when a new customer actually experiences your brand: the confirmation email, the tracking (or lack of it), the unboxing, the first time they use it, and maybe their first support ticket. If you haven’t earned the second order by then, a discount email in February usually won’t do it.

On one audit this fall, the brand’s goal was moving 30-day repeat purchases from about 7.5% to 10%. When we dug in, the biggest opportunities weren’t a better offer. They were missing tracking, delivery info that didn’t match across the site, checkout and emails, and post-purchase and win-back flows that were barely built out. In other words: retention problems that looked like support problems.

Your 30-day plan for BFCM buyers ✅

  1. Day 0: Set expectations. One realistic delivery date, the same everywhere (site, checkout, confirmation email). If peak volume pushes you back, say so up front.

  2. In transit: Get ahead of “where’s my order?” Real tracking links, plus a proactive heads-up the moment something is delayed. The best WISMO ticket is the one that never gets sent.

  3. 2–5 days after delivery: Teach, don’t sell. How to use it, care for it, get the most out of it. This is where you prevent “it doesn’t work” returns and refunds, not just bad reviews.

  4. Days 10–14: Check in like a human. A short “how’s it going?” email they can reply to, with replies routed straight to your support team. Fix problems here, then ask the happy customers for a review.

  5. Days 21–30: Give them a reason to come back. Base it on what they bought: refill timing, the product that pairs with it, a subscription option or loyalty points they’ve already earned. Not another “20% off everything.”

And loop in your support team: tag first-time BFCM buyers in your help desk so their first ticket gets fast, generous, solve-it-in-one-reply treatment. A great first support experience does more for that second order than any flow.

The discount trap 🪤

If every touchpoint after Black Friday is another sale, you’re teaching new customers to wait for the next one. Lead with value and experience. Save the discount for a targeted nudge, not your default.

Measure it separately 📊

Don’t let BFCM buyers disappear into your overall repeat rate. In Shopify, the Customer cohort analysis report groups customers by their first order date. Pull last year’s Black Friday week now to get your baseline, then watch this year’s (the week of Nov 27) at 30, 60 and 90 days. If the number doesn’t move, you’ll know which step in your plan is leaking.

Forward this to whoever owns your post-purchase emails. They’ll thank you in January 🙏

🎙️ LET’S LAUGH ABOUT IT 🎙️

Missed this week’s episode? Ep 2 is out now with Domonique Brown, Senior Director + Head of Customer Experience at Liquid I.V. 💧 We talk about scaling CX through hypergrowth, getting the whole business to listen to the voice of the customer, and how AI is changing the way brands build relationships with customers. Give it a listen before BFCM hits.

Listen / Watch Here:
YouTube
Spotify
Apple Podcasts

Catch up on Ep 1 with Mia Chapa from Glamnetic on YouTube, and follow Let’s Laugh About It on Instagram, TikTok and LinkedIn. New episodes drop every Thursday.

💌 Dear Zoe… 💌

Need to vent? Got a customer story that still has you giggling (or cringing)? I’m trying out a new segment on Let’s Laugh About It called “Dear Zoe…” 🎙️

You send me your laughable business moments: a mistake you (or someone else 👀) made at work, a moment you definitely weren’t laughing about then but can now, or something that was just straight-up hilarious. Want advice? I’ll give it. Just need to vent and make everyone else laugh? Also very welcome. Anonymous or not, your choice!

Send me your “Dear Zoe…” by emailing [email protected] with the subject line “Dear Zoe,” or reply to this email. Yours could end up on the pod 😉

💬 Question of the Week 💬

What’s the most creative excuse you’ve ever heard (or used 👀) for being late?

Hit reply. Best one gets featured next week 😂

👩🏽‍💻 CX JOB BOARD 👩🏽‍💻

Looking for your next CX role?

I’m keeping an eye out for great opportunities across CX, ecommerce, retention + more and sharing some of my favorites here.

CX Operations Analyst @ OLIPOP
Remote · Join Anne Dyer’s team (yes, that Anne from the pod 🥤) and own the systems, tooling and cross-functional relationships that help the whole CX team perform at its best. Apply here

Hiring for a CX role? Reply with the listing and we may add it to next week’s Job Board

🚨 Inevitable Agency CX Audits 🚨

Do you actually know what happens to your BFCM customers after the box lands? 👀

That’s exactly what a CX Audit digs into: we shop your post-purchase experience like a customer, audit your order, shipping and post-purchase flows, look at what first-time buyers are writing in about, and build the 30-day plan that turns BFCM buyers into repeat customers before peak season hits.

Let us reduce your stress and create experiences you’re proud of. Book your CX Audit with the Inevitable Agency team.